IMG_0147_zpsyymsdndh

SimHQ Review 9/10

Fred “HeinKill” Williams from SimHQ has reviewed Atlantic Fleet and took some time to interview Nils Duecker, the lead artist for the game.

Atlantic Fleet scored a 9/10 and Fred had the following to say:
“This impressive game costs about the same as a fast food meal, but offers you a three course dinner you won’t tire of.”
“And honestly, I am simply gobsmacked that this level of detail is even included in a 10 USD iOS title.”

Read the full review & interview here.

226 Responses to “SimHQ Review 9/10”

  1. DigestedSine561

    Oh, and Killerfish Games: please please please give AI captains of damaged submarines some balls! If they engage a ship, they just run away, even if the sub has taken no damage, so to speak, perhaps a single 4.7in hit or less. How does this make your sub unable to engage ships? To make matters worse, they aren’t repaired, so they cruise around sinking merchants while being practically invincible! Please do something about this before I strangle Karl Donitz myself…

    Reply
  2. gm11

    Killerfish Games, I read this review, and it says you’re making a new naval real-time strategy game? Is it gonna have Cold War, and modern ships, or will it still be historical?

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      We’re not ready to announce it yet. Give us a few more months to get it better defined :)

      Reply
      • adons

        I too read the review and it says you are working on a real time strategy game now. Please don’t give up completely on turn-based strategy games. This is a major differentiator of your previous two games. For me Pacific & Atlantic Fleets together with Sid Meyer’s WWI and WW2 planes games for iOS were the best true strategy games mainly due to turn based philosophy that was excellently implemented within the scope of each game.
        Having said that after playing your two previous games I will buy anything you produce in the future.

        Reply
        • Killerfish Games

          We agree! Real time does not mean real time strategy though. It just means it will play like a full simulation, similar to the Silent Hunter series.

          Reply
  3. gm11

    You also did an amazing job at Atlantic Fleet. It is a lot better than Battle Fleet 2, the only advantage that Battle Fleet 2 has over you is online multiplayer. This is the best naval game on mobile. I hope you will do even better with your next game.

    I hope there will be online multiplayer in your next game.

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      Thanks! Multiplayer would be a great feature but we tend to focus on rich, detailed games and the pacing of them is not always conducive to multiplayer.
      It is also a lower priority since there are so many multiplayer naval games already out there, but at the end of the day there’s no denying it would be an awesome feature to have…

      Reply
  4. Nuclear moose

    Dear killerfish I know I’ve said this a lot but there are two things I really want: KMS Emden and Japanese subs from the Yangai missions. Those would be GREAT features! Thanks

    Reply
  5. DigestedSine561

    Two points: Firstly, IK didn’t think the AI was supposed to use unlockables – one night in late-1942, Exeter’s cruiser division ran straight into German battleship Hutten! I’ve unlocked but not purchased Lion and so I was understandably perplexed as to how it arrived.
    Secondly, my squadron (CA Exeter and CL Achilles) managed to sink Hutten in short order. Exeter, which started off on medium damage, got put on heavy damage whilst Achilles failed to take a hit purely because I aimed for the BB, laid smoke, and charged. When I got to a range of 5,000 yards, I turned and fired torpedoes, four altogether due to low ammunition. Exeter’s one missed but Achilles landed three hits – and blew the main magazine. I was on the easiest difficulty, fair enough, but should three torpedoes really sink the largest battleship in commission in the game?

    Reply
  6. DigestedSine561

    And I’ve just discovered an absolutely intriguing glitch. In the North Sea, destroyers Jackal and Vanity were attacked by Do217 torpedo planes. I evaded the first torpedo and the second aircraft, attacking Jackal, had to abort its run to avoid crashing into Vanity. It curved away like normal. However, when it finished curving away and despawned, the torpedo was left floating and gradually began to fall, perhaps at the same rate as depth charges. Over the next few turns, it fell into the water when, upon hitting the water, it splashed in and continued running like a normal torpedo! What the hell?

    Reply
  7. Nuclear moose

    Killerfish I found two bugs while I was playing: 1.the escort carrier Barnes when it launches an attack sometimes there was a big splash and it was basically plane crash into the water move. 2. In the same round one of the bogue class escort carriers launched an attack but while the plane was approaching Bismarcks flak started shooting but I couldn’t see it but could still hear and the invisible flak shot down the plane

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      Were you playing the Barnes or the AI? Did this happen early, or after you had launched several flights of torpedo bombers? There is a bug where >12 (or 16??) aerial torpedoes causes a bug. Fixed in next update.

      Reply
  8. DigestedSine561

    Would it also be possible to add the destruction of propulsion systems? I think this should happen because smaller warships, such as destroyers and light cruisers, shouldn’t be able to repair damage to their engines after being torpedoed or hit by large calibre artillery. I also think that Bismarck found to her cost the rudders simply can’t be repaired whilst at sea!

    Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      CA: Fourth Hipper-class
      Fourth Deutschland-class
      P-class panzerschiffe
      CL: Emden
      Z-plan CLs (Can’t remember the name)
      British D- and E-class
      CV: Ark Royal-class
      Eagle-class
      Graf Zeppelin-class
      Seydlitz-class
      Europa-class
      SS: U-class
      Type XXI Elektroboot
      Type XIV Milchkuk
      Seehunds
      Plus the U.S. Atlantic Fleet incl. Fletchers, Casablancas, DEs, Wasp, Yorktown, North Carolina… etc.

      Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      In fact, let me just completely rewrite my list. I would like:
      Battleships/battle cruisers:
      Remaining Lion-class
      Remaining Hutten-class
      Heavy cruisers/panzerschiffe
      Hawkins-class
      Remaining Admiral Hipper-class/P-class
      Light cruisers:
      C-class CLAA/D- and E-class
      Emden-class/M-class (standard)/M-class (advanced)/Spahkreuzer 1938
      Aircraft carriers:
      Ark Royal-class/Eagle-class
      Graf Zeppelin-class/Europa-class/Weser-class (aka Seydlitz-class)/Gneisenau-class/Potsdam-class
      Destroyers:
      Hunt I-class/Hunt III-class
      Type 1936C/Type 1938A/Type 1938Ac/Type 1938B/Type 1942/Type 1944/Type 1945
      More German torpedo boats
      Submarines:
      U-class
      Type XXI Elektroboot/Type XIV Milchkuk/Seehund
      That satisfy you?

      Reply
      • Nuclear moose

        Yep:) the ships I want are (some of these might be the ones you mentioned) 1.carriers: Hms Unicorn, Hms audicity, Hms Hermes,Hms Eagle,USS Ranger,U.S.S Wasp and Italian carrier Aquila . 1.crusiers: Kms Emden, Emerald class light crusier, Hawkins class heavy crusier, arethusa class lightcrusier. 3:submarines: allies:U.S.S Gato and U.S.S Balao class subs British U-Class subs,Grampus class subs and, S class subs. :Axis X, XX1 and, jap subs from the Yangai missions. How do you like my suggestions?

        Reply
        • DigestedSine561

          Yeah, I forgot about Grampus- and Arethusa- class ships. I also like the Aquila idea – I like converted ships like Eagle, Lexington Akagi and Europa.

          Reply
        • gm11

          How did you know that? There is already a game from the creators of Gunship called “Wings of Duty”, but it’s for iOS only. I play that. It’s really good, and it’s the closest game to War Thunder on mobile.

          What’s you username there?

          I have the Zero, P-40, Ki-43, and F4F.

          Reply
          • gm11

            F6F Hellcat, B5N Kate, and P-39 Airacobra now have gameplay videos. They are all on the gunship3d YouTube channel. Guadalcanal was in the gameplay videos.

            Update might come out this week.

      • DigestedSine561

        I’ve remembered another ship class I’d like – the British Town-class (ex-American Wickes- and Clemson-class)

        Reply
      • Rayydar

        Impressive list. Agree especially to Ark Royal and Hunt class – most of the DDs in the later Single Battles were in fact Hunts.
        Btw, the correct name for Type XIV is Milchkuh (dairy cow), not Milchkuk. ;)

        Reply
      • Anonymous

        I think you forgot something

        “quote”-
        Plus the U.S. Atlantic Fleet incl. Fletchers, Casablancas, DEs, Wasp, Yorktown, North Carolina… etc.

        Reply
  9. Nuclear moose

    1.killrfish I have a suggestion for the third game your making! WW1 Naval combat that would be a great game! 2.I have a payload for TBF Avenger :FIDO Mark 24 mine anti submarine torpedo. Thanks:)

    Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      The FIDO homing torpedo would be epic! It might convince me to buy escort carriers!

      Reply
        • gm11

          That game hasn’t been released yet. I heard of it, and it’s very much like Silent Hunter, but for mobile.

          Reply
          • gm11

            I saw the tech demos of Wolves of the Atlantic, but there aren’t actually gameplay videos yet. It’s been in development for several years already, and from what I’ve seen, it’s a lot better than Silent Hunter 5.

          • Nuclear moose

            Gm11 when do you want to play wings of duty (I have all the planes), do you think Japanese subs would be a good idea for Atlantic fleet?

  10. DigestedSine561

    Can we also have torpedoes run for one final turn after all ships are sunk (not if they disengage though) because I just had 8 torpedoes not 100 yards from Renown when she sank my final ship!

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      We attempted to do this, but it broke the turn sequence and turned out to be a significant amount of work to get this feature into the game.

      Reply
      • Nuclear moose

        Killerfish PLEASE tell us or give us an estimate on when the next update comes out

        Reply
        • Killerfish Games

          Still working on it. We plan to add a few improvements to the game as well as bug fixes.

          Reply
          • Anonymous

            Will there be more of the US Navy
            please reply
            but you don’t have to say yes or no just write that it maybe spoilers to say something

  11. gm11

    Killerfish Games, are we going to get more U.S. Navy ships in the future? I remember suggestions of the Iowa, and Montana to be added, and the carrier Yorktown.

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      Gm11 Im just shocked Wota is made by 1 person and I can’t wait to fly the fa-330 and take command of Japanese submarines:)

      Reply
  12. Anonymous

    Killerfishgames I find the carrier top priority thing is unrealistic and breaks the game because

    1.the germans saw battleships as higher priority it was in the Pacific that they realised carriers were the most important assets
    2.If a battleships hits a carrier deck it disables the carrier instantly making carriers just there for show
    3.the crew of the bismarck prioritised sinking older battleships first

    also the germans had pre dreadnoughts in WW2

    Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      1. I do find that surface ships and submarines should perhaps be a priority; check the lists above that I’ve made to show all of the vessels I’d like to see in the game.
      2. That is irritating, but on the other hand if you only encounter a destroyer squadron, say three DDs and a CL, you can decimate them with bombs and fish before they get close enough to knock out your deck. And even if they damage it, you have up to four turns to finish them off before you run out of attack capabilities… and then you get to escorts – a handy smoke screen and a decoy, a CA or a BB, can divert enemy fire enabling the carrier to run.
      3. Perhaps so… and look where it bloody got them.
      4. If the High Seas Fleet commanders nicknamed the pre-dreadnoughts at Jutland “five-second ships” as that’s how long they were expected to last under fire from the Grand Fleet, how long do you think it would take for Holstein to sink against a ship like Nelson? No, they are coastal battleships and bombardment ships only, and so until land bombardment comes in, it is pointless including such ships.

      Reply
  13. DigestedSine561

    Killerfish games, can we please have two things for the dynamic campaign either in this game or in the next:
    The option to toggle 20 or 40 ships in your navy. If this makes it too easy to get unlocks, disable unlocks for the 40 ship navy. I think that this would greatly enhance the ‘fleet at your fingertips’ feeling that the dynamic campaign gives you and I guess is supposed to give you.
    The option to toggle preset ships or a stash of renown. Whilst I appreciate your selection of ships, I find that it may be nice to start with slightly better ships, or at least variants in the class (for example, I hate the name ‘Vanoc’ and would much rather have a ship such as Vendetta but I don’t want to pettily waste renown).
    Please consider these things,
    DigestedSine561

    Reply
  14. Anonymous

    Just something worth noting-The American ships had highly developed radar aimed fire control and therefor is US battleships are added they should have radar instead of rangefinders-the South Dakota also was heavily damaged by the krishima because the shockwaves of the 16inch guns caused major power failure.Then USS Washington appeared and sunk krishima with accurate radar aimed fire.

    AND best of all South Dakota went to the North Atlantic in 1943
    Washington went on the 26 March 1942

    Reply
  15. gm11

    Nuclear moose, Japanese submarines might be a good idea. If they are added, I would want the Sentaka-ko, I-201 (Sentaka(Dai) class, Sentoku type (a submarine aircraft carrier) with three Aichi M6A, so Axis can launch fighters. They have many more submarine types.

    If Montana is added, should Yamato be added to the game for Axis? Also, what about Italy’s Littorio-class battleship?

    Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      You’d need type B-1 and Type J-3 really… and Yamato should keep out of it because it stayed in the Pacific whereas it’s highly likely at least one of the Montanas would have been on convoy escort duties.

      Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      I think those are great ideas but i would also want more carriers like Hms,ark royal ,eagle, Hermes, and ranger. And if their next game is pacific fleet 2 do you think U-Boats and Armed Merchant Crusiers would be appropriate?

      Reply
  16. DigestedSine561

    I’ve discovered another glitch; one dark night, submarine HMS Tigris attacked Scharnhorst’s screen in the Irminger Sea and attacked and sank Z.2 Georg Thiele. The next action, in the SAME TURN, was Tigris attacking Graf Spee off Kiel, failing to score a hit. The Kreigsmarine is doomed! The British have mastered teleporting!

    Reply
  17. DigestedSine561

    I’ve just re-read the article – please no real-time! Your turn-based games are almost impeccable but no-one can make a good real-time game on a phone – the controls always get in your way and, with the functions of Atlantic Fleet, it would be damn-near impossible to make it good. It won’t end up as good as Atlantic Fleet is, I’m warning you now.

    Reply
    • gm11

      A real-time game? It’s possible on mobile, and mobile devices are already getting more powerful. Battlestations Pacific was a real time strategy game, and it got it right. Also, Wolves of the Atlantic is real time. There’s a possibility that real time naval warfare could work on mobile.

      Reply
      • DigestedSine561

        The Battlestations series are both very good games – but they’re not mobile. I’m just worried that to, for example, to have directional and weaponry controls the same as Atlantic Fleet, you’d either have overlapping controls or they’d have to be moved which would obscure the screen. Battlestations: Midway and Battlestations: Pacific only work because on consoles and computers there is plenty of space for different commands – an entire controller or keyboard and mouse to give commands instead of a tiny screen which needs to display what’s happening AS WELL.

        Reply
          • DigestedSine561

            See, iPad only! That’s because real-time games don’t work on smaller devices such as phones or my iPod Touch!

          • DigestedSine561

            And I also hate to point it out, but from the trailer and pictures on their website the graphics look cr*p and the gameplay looks a tad boring. I’m very picky in what I want in a game and Atlantic Fleet seems to – pretty much – have it all, bar a few more vessels and a few little bugs. Now, I’m not denying that an RTS won’t work, I’m just saying it’ll be harder for it to work than a turn-based game. I think that, in my opinion, Killerfish games’ best bet for a new game is to remain turn-based as we know that’s popular and works well and to revisit the Pacific because, whilst it was a good game at the time, Pacific Fleet is overshadowed by Atlantic Fleet and doesn’t really do justice to the theatre nicknamed the Naval War without things such as damaged components, smoke and more than 14 warships.

          • gm11

            Victory at Sea is very demanding. It only works on 64-bit devices.

          • gm11

            Also, there is speculation that Wargaming will make a mobile version of “World of Warships”, which recently started open beta, called “World of Warships Blitz”, but it will take years to do that.

      • Nuclear moose

        Hey guys I’m sorry I haven’t replayed lately I was somewhere with no wifi. And gm11 when do you want to play wings of duty?

        Reply
          • Nuclear moose

            Gm11 I know your name is goldmaster in wings of duty (I’m sunthorn) thanks for posting some of the planes I asked you about on the forum :)

          • gm11

            Me-262 isn’t confirmed, I asked for Ta-152 on the forum, but I don’t have any response from the creator of game, just their moderators, and a few other members. The Ta-152 did see combat though.

          • gm11

            Also, the Aichi D3A hasn’t been confirmed, but the forum’s members are in support of adding it. I also asked for P-36, A6M2-N Rufe, they don’t want the Rufe, and P-36 should have been the starter instead of P-35. I don’t think they will add Brewster Buffalo.

  18. 5

    Bugs/Issues
    Pinguin class merchant raiders obtain damage efgects to their C turret despite the fact it remains operational.

    I found that on rare occasions, I get aircraft that drop double their normal payload (16 rockets on Liberators, 6 bombs on Swordfish, etc.).

    If you stop a Lion class battleship, you will clearly see that a section of its hull forword of the rudder is missing. It isn’t good if you can see the machinery.

    Questions
    Are hedgehog suppose to be able to damage/sink surface ships? I found that they can. I tested it on Scharnhorst and sank it with a hedgehog equipped destroyer in custom battle.

    Do aircraft do damage if they collide with a ship similar to Pacific Fleet? In other words, if I shot down a Condor, and it hit an Illustrious class aircraft carrier, would the ship take damage?

    Do secondary guns and torpedoes ever get knocked out or do they just experience damage that renders them unusable for X amount of turns?

    Reply
    • Anonymous

      well I guess if you throw some hi powered TNT on a battleship then probably

      how many hits?

      Reply
    • gm11

      I can’t seem to knock out secondary guns on capital ships too. I can only jam them, and make them orange in the damage report.

      Reply
      • DigestedSine561

        It IS possible for today my Lützow had the port secondaries completely offline while attacking a convoy – damage caused by a RN submarine.

        Reply
  19. Jose Buelvas

    Hola como estan I would like to make a proposal for the upgrade game atlantic fleet, next submarines are a little faster it reaches the maximum is about 9 km and that’s no good to fight and should give a manual with graphic instructions each class of destroyers and aircraft carriers battleships cruise ships.
    And if they take a new naval game that I hope they do it as fleet pacific that actually tastes better it is American and kosher boats ose, it’s pacific fleet, but with graphics of fleet atlantic and put more ships by the real Japanese imperial army had many more ships like the Fuso Nagato kirishima Shukaku and many others instead give us one of each kind and not all classes are in the United States lack the mountain class, North Carolina, Arizona and here it is the only battleship iowa.
    And I think I speak not only I think many have seen those aspects that have to improve is not a bad review are just things that I would like that would improve and not say what I say tomorrow to do so in a while. If you read Thanks and keep it up.

    Reply
  20. Anonymous

    Can we have an option on dynamic campaign to have up to 6 ships instead of three

    Reply
    • gm11

      I think that is simplified campaign, not dynamic. The developers wanted to increase the diffficulty, and give the enemy the numerical advantage, since later missions are supposed to be harder.

      Reply
  21. Jose Buelvas

    Hello doubt whether or not it will be a mistake of the game ….
    but you sometimes game mode “Battle for the Atlantic” I get Lion class battleships and sometimes do not show me what happens?

    Reply
  22. Morgan

    I was just wondering if you could add the British vanguard class battleship. Also just for my curiosity how much time on average does it take to model a ship for your games?

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      Vanguard was commissioned after the war, so she’s not a top priority.
      A capital ship takes up to 2 weeks to model.

      Reply
  23. Nuclear moose

    Killerfish can you give us an estimate for when the next update comes out and what will be in the next update?

    Reply
  24. Tobster

    Bug found with winning the battle of the Atlantic, Lion class only show up on the Battle of the Atlantic and not free play/ campaign ect. Would be nice if this was fixed soon please :)

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      Intentional: BotA win unlocks ships for future BotA games.
      Campaign win unlocks ships for future campaigns and Custom Battles.

      Reply
  25. Jose Buelvas

    Killerfish wondering if you could tell me how to unlock the Class -H aacorazados and whether they could put the British battleships Class -Lion

    Reply
    • gm11

      You will needs get 3 stars in mission 50 for both Allies and Axis. If you win Battle of the Atlantic for either, the secret battleship of the respective side you play will be unlocked.

      Reply
      • Anonymous

        Hang on a sec is it 3 stars on both Allies and axis for both lion and H or Allies for Lion or Axis for H

        Reply
        • DigestedSine561

          Getting 3 stars for the Brits will get the Lion without 3 stars on the German side and vice versa.

          Reply
      • Nuclear moose

        Killerfish I encountered a bug while playing as korman. I torpedoed a county class heavy crusier (Canberra) and when the torpedo hit it said “torpedo failed to arm” but the torpedo sank Canberra with signs showing that the torpedo blew up

        Reply
    • gm11

      The Lion-class battleship is already in the game. You need to unlock it. You must win Battle of the Atlantic as Allies to be able to use it in dynamic campaign. Or you can also unlock it by getting 3 stars in the final simplified campaign mission for the Allies.

      You unlock the H-class battleship the same way, except that you have to play as Germany.

      Reply
  26. DigestedSine561

    Would it be possible for you to add about six camouflages per class of ship and then randomise the camouflage for merchants and assign them for warships.

    Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      Yes, but it makes the game larger and use more RAM.
      This is a feature we’re looking into for the PC/Mac versions.

      Reply
      • DigestedSine561

        “Looking into it”.
        *sigh*
        Oh and Killerfish Games, I’ve just upgraded my PC to Windows 10 and now I can’t post responses here, I have to use my iPod which isn’t ideal.

        Reply
  27. Shawnlp

    Hey I heard the iPod touch 5th generation was discontuned! When the iPod touch 6th generation came along. Is the iPod 6g compatible with this game?

    Reply
    • gm11

      It is much more than powerful enough to run the game. Also, you will have Metal API support, because the CPU is 64-bit. It will run smoothly.

      Reply
  28. gm11

    Killerfish Games, I cannot damage surface ships with depth charges. Is this intentional, or a bug? Even if they hit the ship’s deck, it will go underwater, and explode beneath the surface ship, causing no damage at all.

    Reply
  29. Morgan

    Does anyone have any tips for beating the final British campaign level? I have tryed many times before and can’t seem to beat it.

    Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      Pick Bismarck, Tirpitz and Scharnhorst and keep restarting until you cross their T. Ignore your weapons officer’s recommendations and use your own judgement to fire. Destroy enemy main batteries and immobilise the battleships. DO NOT SINK THEM or when two go
      Under the other two lay smoke. Keep your eye on the DDs and only hit them when they try to torpedo you. After all four BBs are disabled, sink any remaining DDs and close in for the kill, using Scharnhorst’s torpedoes to good effect.

      Reply
  30. SilentAssassin101

    Conjratulations KillerFish and all the people behind this game. I can’t wait till the next one ( should you make one)! I must say the british campain is slighty harder than the german one especially mision 6 to start with. U-boats all most one the war and I can’t use nazi aircraft! Please explain. Apart from this this game is a hunge succses. 8.5/10

    Reply
    • gm11

      German planes are available only in Battle of the Atlantic, not in simplified campaign. Also, they are only available in certain areas in the map.

      Reply
  31. gm11

    Nuclear moose, you need to buy P-40 with gold, and fully upgraded first before you can get P-39. Also, you will need F4F that is upgraded before you get F6F.

    Also, that trick to earn gold without spending money does not work anymore, since 0.4.0.

    I also found out that Philip has over 100000 gold in his account, through the new gameplay videos.

    Reply
  32. gm11

    Also, has anybody tried sinking the Lion class battleship, or H-class battleship using less powerful ships? I’ve been able to sink Lion with a pocket battleship, and Scharnhorst.

    What I also find that it is really challenging to destroy a Lion with an Admiral Hipper-class heavy cruiser.

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      Gm11 can you do me a favor? I found a bug but can’t report. So can you post it for me and tell Phillip Sunthorn found this. Here’s the bug: while I’m getting ready for take or I’m in the air the picture looks real grainy. Do this for me please:)

      Reply
  33. gm11

    To take screenshot of screen on iOS, press both the power button, and home button at the same time. Do this when you see the bug that you have reported.

    Reply
      • gm11

        Did you take the screenshot, and upload? It it’s uploaded, do you know the link?

        I’m gonna save a copy that image, and I’ll post it on the forum.

        Reply
        • Nuclear moose

          I might not have to post it to the website because tommorow I might be able to join the forum:)

          Reply
  34. Nuclear moose

    Killerfish can we have some info about the update yet? (Sorry I just really want some info)

    Reply
  35. Nuclear moose

    Gm11 do you think a ww1 naval combat game would be cool (if I’m not on the forum by sept.1 please say something about the invasion of Poland for me)

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      Killerfish PLEASE add barcudda in custom I got the game in May and I have never gotten to fly it :| PLEASE ADD IT (sorry)

      Reply
      • Nuclear moose

        Gm11 I need help I made multiple accounts on one device and now I can’t make a real account on the forum. What do I do:(

        Reply
  36. gm11

    Go to profile when you are logged in, look at the left, you will see “Actions”. Below it, you will see “Delete this account”.

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      I haven’t been able to sign in and how long does it take to get the activation email?

      Reply
      • gm11

        I don’t know. Because registeration didn’t need to be approved when I joined, I got mine immediately.

        Reply
    • Killerfish Games

      No. Ship classes are based on lead ship or most numerous. Unfortunately we can’t model individual variants within a class.

      Reply
      • Nuclear moose

        Killerfish I have a suggestion and a bug. 1.I’ve noticed sometimes when one of my torpedoes hits a ship it will act like nothing happened it won’t list,it shows no signs of damage, example: I hit a torpedo boat right smack in the middle but it shows no signs of damage or even a hole! 2. Jap subs f om yangai missions

        Reply
  37. Nuclear moose

    Gm11 if you like shocking history facts I have one for you: Planned Imperial German Invasion of the United States 2 decades before ww1. Recently discovered in 2002. The reason? Germany is jealous of Britain,France,and America of its success in economic trade. How Germany plans to earn itself a spot in shipping: Not quonquer the U.S but force it into negotiation and drastically reduce its success in economic trade. There were three plans.

    1.plan 1. Send a massive fleet of ships,engage the U.S Navy in battle,defeat the U.S Navy, and bombard Norfolk Naval yard and other important sites

    2. Plan 2. Send a large fleet of transports and escorts (about 40-60 ships). Land troops at sandy hook,New Jersey and shell New York City to terrorize civilians and land at Cape Cod,Massachusetts and shell Boston with the same intentions as newyork and force the U.S to the negotiating table.

    3.Plan 3. I have trouble understanding this one sorry.

    Why it wouldn’t work: Germany simply didn’t have enough ships,men, and resources thank goodness and plus after the Spanish-American war the U.S Navy was built up and pumped up for battle

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      Thank you gm11 for telling admin and everyone how to help get on the forum some how :)

      Reply
  38. the_patroller55

    Will you add Aircraft Carriers for the Kreigsmarine? I mean the Graf Zeppelin-class and proposed convertions.

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      I was using a fake one because I thought it would send me info I didn’t need and yes I checked my spam foldet

      Reply
  39. Nuclear moose

    I already tried my dad’s email on my ipad but my moms however, I haven’t tried so I’ll try to make one on her phone

    Reply
  40. Nuclear moose

    I already tried my dad’s email on my ipad but my moms however, I haven’t tried so I’ll try to make one on her phone

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      Hey gm11 can you find any records of the corsair and hellcat over Europe? What roles they played,if they scored and air to air kills or if any of them were captured

      Reply
      • gm11

        The RN FAA received its first Corsairs in November 1943. The Corsair was used in an attack on the Tirpitz, on April 3, 1944. Also, the British were the ones that were able to land the F4U on carriers, so that’s how the USN approved the F4U for carrier service.

        The Hellcat was used by the Royal Navy, in Europe, and the Medditeranean theatre.

        Reply
        • Nuclear moose

          I also read that the hellcat was used in operation dragoon (which they need to teach us about in history). The invasion of southern France. I read they were very successful in ground attack and air to air combat. Did the corsair get any kills? (The part about the British showing the Americans that the corsair could be landed on a carrier was fascinating) and were any corsairs or hellcats captured by the Germans?

          Reply
          • gm11

            The Corsair has no kills. The Germans may have also captured 1, or 2 Corsairs. The Japanese captured 2. There was an F4U in the Kasumigaura flight school. There is even a photograph of the Japanese Corsair.

  41. DigestedSine561

    Killerfish games, check the line-up for the Ile de Batz – it appears to be not only the same Les Sept Iles but fails to use T-24 and T-29 which appear in the overview.

    Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      I also notice the British destroyer isn’t noted as scuttled in le sept isles the one where the dido class crusier is sunk

      Reply
    • Nuclear moose

      I also notice the British destroyer isn’t noted as scuttled in le sept isles the one where the dido class crusier is sunk by tp boats

      Reply
  42. gm11

    Killerfish, I may have noticed a problem with the light cruiser Edinburgh in its mission where it is being towed by destroyers. The Edinburgh suddenly sped up to more than 60 knots.

    Reply
  43. Nuclear moose

    Will the destroyer also be listed as scuttled in les eptiles the one where Charybdis is sunk?

    P.S can you give us some info what the new update will have?

    P.S.S what month will you tell us what your new game will be?

    Reply
  44. Nuclear moose

    What are some strange history facts you know? I’ll start off

    The dog that passed his owner in rank. Sargent Stubby was a dog that was smuggled over seas by his owner Robert J.Conroy. When Stubby got over to France he was found out but when Stubby sensed trouble, he saluted his commander impressing him and allowing him to stay. Stubby went on to be very useful to the 102nd division. Whimpering to alert the division of a mustard gas attack, barking to alert incoming shells because he could hear them before humans,helping locate wounded soldiers,bringing comfort to the wounded and well soldiers,and even capturing a German spy! He won 10 medals and became a Sargent in world war one

    Reply
    • DigestedSine561

      More on dogs, the captain of US fleet carrier Lexington had a spaniel (I think he was called Wags) who was not only present at the carrier’s destruction in the Coral Sea but survived to
      tell the tail! (sorry for the pun)

      Reply
      • Nuclear moose

        More on animals: There was a cat that survived the sinking of 3 ships! Her name was Unsinkable Sam she was onboard the Kms Bismarck, Hms Cossack,and Hms Ark Royal. A commander said “He was angry but quite unharmed. I would be mad to if my mouse hunting was interrupted by a torpedo to!”

        Reply
  45. gm11

    What the moderator said to Nuclear moose:

    They probably:

    Did not type it right.
    Did not check slam/trash folder.
    Or somehow did not register properly.

    If they didn’t receive an activation email they should email me so I can try getting a notification to help them out, but I can’t send activation emails. Why use a fake email? If you don’t want any messages just opt out and unsubscribe from any advertisements.

    Reply
  46. Nuclear moose

    Hey gm11 can you PLEASE PLEASE PLEAS PLEASE PLEASE tell me how to get pink typing in gs3 Vietnam?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)